E-mail the WS Director
Contact the Drew Webmaster
Back to WS Main Page

WMSTG 712: Interdisciplinary Seminar
in Women's Studies
Fall 2000

 

Wendy Kolmar
(S.W. Bowne 112, Ext. 3632)

Virginia Burrus
(Seminary Hall 112, Ext. 3099)

COURSE OBJECTIVES:
--To build a common ground and common vocabulary among graduate students interested in pursuing women's studies and feminist scholarship in their fields;

--To foster interdisciplinary conversation in women's studies among students and faculty in all the graduate areas;

--To help students strengthen their theoretical groundwork for graduate study in women's studies and feminist scholarship in the disciplines.

--To create an opportunity for students to continue exploring interdisciplinary feminist theory or feminist theory in their fields.


TEXTS:

Wendy Kolmar and Frances Bartkowski, eds. Feminist Theory: A Reader (1999)
Elizabeth Minnich, Transforming Knowledge (1991)
Jeanette Winterson, Written on the Body (1994)
Additional articles.

SCHEDULE
Sept 6 Introduction to the Course
Sept 13 Minnich, Transforming Knowledge
Sept 20 Defining Woman/Women
Simone de Beauvoir, from The Second Sex [FTR: 145-155]
Firestone, from Dialectic of Sex [FTR: 183-187]
Ortner, "Is Female to Male as Nature Is to Culture?" [FTR: 203-211]
Lorde, "Age, Race, Sex, Class: Women Redefining Difference" [FTR: 288-293]
Irigaray, from This Sex Which Is Not One [FTR: 277-282]
Fuss, "The Risk of Essence" [FTR: 423-432]

Sept 27 Defining Feminism & Feminist Thought
Delmar, "What is Feminism?" [copy]
hooks, "Feminism: A Transformational Politic" [FTR: 432-437]
Harding, "Reinventing Ourselves as Other" [copy]
Collins, from "Black Feminist Thought" [FTR 478-483]
Alcoff, "Cultural Feminism vs. Post Structuralism. . ." [FTR 403-414]
Oct 4 Gender, Race, Nation
Uma Narayan, "Contesting Cultures: "Westernization," Respect for Cultutre and Third World Feminists"
Gayatri Spivak, "Three Women's Texts and a Critique of Imperialism"
Lutz & Collins, "The Color of Sex" [copy]
Anzaldua, "La Conscienzia de la Mestiza: Towards a New Consciousness" [FTR, 398-403]

Oct 11 Grad/Theo Reading Week
Oct 18 Gender, Sex, Sexuality
Catharine A. MacKinnon, "Sexuality," from Toward a Feminist Theory of the State (p. 437, FTR);
Radicalesbians, "The Woman Identified Woman" (p. 195, FTR);
Marilyn Frye,"Some Reflections on Separatism and Power" (p. 282, FTR);
Monique Wittig,"The Straight Mind" (p. 299, FTR);
Adrienne Rich, "CompulsoryHeterosexuality and Lesbian Existence" (p. 304, FTR); Judith Butler, "Against Proper Objects" [copy]
Oct 25 Winterson, Written on the Body

For the next four weeks (dates are tentative!), guests have been invited from a variety of disciplines and have been asked to respond to two questions:
1) What has been the impact of feminist scholarship in your field?
2) How do you see your current work as feminist or as working at an intersection of interdisciplinary feminist scholarship and your disciplinary field?

Nov 1 Guest: Stephen Moore, Biblical Studies
Nov 8 Jill Cermele, Psychology, and Kristin Anderson, Sociology
Nov 15 Guest: Catherine Keller, Theology and Religion
Nov 23 Thanksgiving Break
Nov 29 Guest: Lynn Westfield, Christian Education
Dec 6 Presentations in class and potluck dinner
COURSE REQUIREMENTS:

Abstracts:
For each article assigned, write a one-paragraph (4-5 sentence) abstract. The abstract should include: the main point of the article's argument; several essential subordinate points or examples; a final sentence which locates the article in some way in relation to the topic of the day or the other articles assigned. When the week's reading is a book, select two chapters from the book to abstract. No abstract is required for Written on the Body. Abstracts are due when the readings are discussed in class. Abstracts are an essential part of the work of the course; they will be counted not graded as follows:
Abstracts complete and on time for:

11 classes = A
10 classes = B
9 classes = C

One Presentation on an Assigned Reading (Two Presenters per Class):
For the reading you've been assigned, you will prepare background material for the class to assist in the reading of the text in class. Prepare a one-to-two page handout for the class. Your assignment as the presenter is to provide context, background, definitions and a brief bibliography for the writer of the essay.
1) Look up key terms, provide definitions and consider their use in previous texts we've read. Does the essay, for example, define ‘women,' ‘gender' or ‘sex' differently than another text we are reading for that day or than previous texts we have read.
2) Identify major sources to which the article refers and be prepared to fill us in a little on them. Many are available in an excerpted form in the reader.
3) Provide a 5-10 item bibliogrpahy of the writer's major work
Course Project:
The purpose of the course project is for you to begin or continue your exploration of interdisciplinary feminist scholarship in relation to a particular issue, topic or area of scholarship in your field. The product of this exploration will be a paper that examines the ways that gender, sexuality and/or feminist theory have been deployed as lenses or categories of analysis in the particular area. What debates have these terms generated? In what ways are these categories contested in the particular area you are examining? How has the use of these categories of analysis changed work in the field or area?

Part One: Project Proposal and Short Paper (Due October 18)
A 250-word proposal for your project and five annotations of key sources. In addition to the project proposal, you will write a short paper (5-7 pages) which looks at three of the five articles you have annotated, examining the ways in which they are doing feminist scholarship, the debates that arise between/among them, and the ways that they are defining the field of scholarship you are examining. The purpose of this paper is to practice, on a small scale, the approach that you will use in your longer essay.

Also due on October 18, is the form on which you sign up an outside reader who will read and comment on your final paper. This reader can be any member of the graduate faculty, most likely a member of the women's studies graduate area. When they agree to read the paper they are agreeing to meet with you to discuss the paper and then to read the final draft and provide a grade to us. Consult with the instructors about who would be a possible reader for the paper.

Part Two: Annotated Bibliography (Due Nov. 3)
Develop an annotated bibliography of books and articles in the area (15-20 sources). Each bibliographic entry (use the style preferred in your area), should be accompanied by an annotation that identifies the major issues addressed by the article and the ways in which the approach to those issues is informed by gender/feminist analysis.

Part Three: Essay (Due Nov 15 in draft; Dec. 11 final)
Write and essay of 10-15 pages, in which you examine the materials you have gathered as a body of feminist scholarship. What are the commonalities in methodology or theory among these scholars? What are the debates within this field of scholarship? How does it bring feminist theory and method into dialogue with disciplinary approaches? This essay should not simply be a review of the literature, though it should be well-grounded in your sources. It should be analytical, critical and even speculative in nature (i.e. you might suggest areas to be explored, work yet to be done, approaches to be taken, linkages that the work you're examining doesn't itself foreground.).
A draft version of your essay is due Nov. 15 (bring 3 copies). In class, you will exchange essays with another member of the class. You will comment on each others work, making suggestions for revision. You will also serve as respondents to each others' work when it is presented in class.
After you have received your readers comments, revise your essay on the basis of those comments and also on the basis of comments and responses you've received during your seminar presentation. In you final draft, include an acknowledgment paragraph in which you identify the contributions of others to the development of your essay. Final, revised essays are due, with the annotated bibliography attached, December 11. Deliver a copy to your outside reader and one each to Profs. Kolmar and Burrus.

Participation and Attendance:
This seminar is a collaborative exploration which is only as good as the contribution of each participant. Attendance, preparation and participation are essential to the quality
of everyone's seminar experience.